Cast a Line at These 4 Top Spots for Nantucket Fishing

For centuries, Nantucket has been a haven for fishermen of all sorts. Whether you’re looking to cast your line from one of our sandy beaches or venture out to sea for your biggest catch yet, our tiny Atlantic island doesn’t disappoint. Bring along your pole (or borrow one from one of our seaside stops) and get ready for your greatest angling adventure yet. Here is everything you need to know about Nantucket fishing.  

Ready to plan the rest of your Nantucket getaway? Get our complimentary Vacation Guide, and you’ll have hand-picked recommendations on where to eat and what to do delivered directly to your inbox! Get yours today!

Get the Guide

Everything You Need to Know About Nantucket Fishing

Start planning your next great Nantucket fishing trip today. Cast out on the same shores as some of fishing’s greatest players and bring home more than just fish tales. Here is our guide to all of the best spots to float your bobber this season. 

  • Eel Point

Eel Point is located on the Northwestern side of the island and acts as a peninsula to Madaket Harbor. It’s apart of the Nantucket Conservation Foundation and is home to some of the island’s sprawling mansions and sugary sand beaches. 

The untouched landscape makes it an ideal shelter for flounder and bonito. The shoreline is broad and wide offering plenty of room to share the beach with fellow fishermen and beach-goers. 

  • Cisco Beach

Cisco Beach is a popular spot for surfers and beach borders due to its intense surf and steady current. The beach is not blocked by any harbors or land formations, so it welcomes big fish to its shores. Look out for cusk, halibut, and pollock. Cisco Beach is the perfect day-trip getaway for those looking to escape it all.

  • Coatue Wildlife Refuge

Coskata Coatue Wildlife Refuge is nearly 400 acres of beaches and wooded areas that protect Nantucket Harbor from the Sound. It’s home to some of the island’s most coveted birds and rare plants. 42 acres of the refuge is owned and operated by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, ensuring that all of the area’s rules and regulations are adhered to. You’ll want to pack your mackerel and jigs for this trip and plan to catch a lot of cod.

  • Deep-Sea Fishing Charters

Maybe 30 miles off the coast isn’t enough for you. Venture out to sea with one of the island’s premier fishing charters, such as Captain Tom’s Charters or Albacore Charters. Wave goodbye to the shore as you drift off to find your biggest catch yet!   

Reel Into the Gorgeous Anchor Inn

Greyhound - Full RoomAfter a day of bait and hook, you’ll be ready to rest away at our downtown bed and breakfast. Plan your stay in the cozy Greyhound Room and enjoy a plush queen-size bed, a flat-screen TV, Malin + Goetz bath products, and a complimentary breakfast each morning of your stay. Best of all, you’re within walking distance of the city’s best restaurants and bars!

While you’re busy reeling in your next big catch, it’ll be hard to miss the island’s towering lighthouses. Add a self-guided lighthouse tour to your trip, and you won’t be disappointed. We cannot wait to welcome you to Nantucket!